Majority opinion by Judge Pigott
In a civil case, when a party asks for a missing-witness instruction, the judge can treat the absent witness’s testimony as cumulative only if it would duplicate evidence favoring the party who controls that witness, not just because it would match the other side’s evidence.
Also joined by Graffeo, Lippman, Read, Rivera, and Smith.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
When a missing witness charge—an instruction permitting the jury to draw an adverse inference from a party’s failure to call a witness who would normally be expected to support that party’s version of events—is requested in a civil case, the uncalled witness’s testimony may be considered cumulative only if it is cumulative of testimony or other evidence favoring the party controlling the witness, not merely because it would repeat or be consistent with the opposing party’s evidence.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "An "uncalled witness" or "missing witness" charge instructs a jury that it may draw an adverse inference based on the failure of a party "to call a witness who would normally be expected to support that party's version of events" (People v Savinon)."
- "The jury is instructed that it "may draw the strongest inference that the opposing evidence permits against a witness who fails to testify in a civil proceeding" (Matter of Nassau County Dept. of Social Servs. v Denise J.; see PJI 1:75)."
- "The preconditions for this charge, applicable to both criminal and civil trials, may be set out as follows: (1) the witness's knowledge is material to the trial; (2) the witness is expected to give noncumulative testimony; (3) the witness is under the "control" of the party against whom the charge is sought, so that the witness would be expected to testify in that party's favor; and (4) the witness is available to that party (see Savinon; People v Macana; People v Gonzalez; see also e.g. Brueckner v Simpson). Here, the defendants do not deny that their witnesses' knowledge was material or that their relationship with the uncalled witnesses makes it natural to expect that the witnesses would testify in their favor; and they do not deny the uncalled witnesses' availability. Rather, defendants argue that the testimony of the uncalled witnesses would have been "cumulative of the plaintiff's treating physician and plaintiff's radiology expert," relying on Getlin. We reject, as a matter of law, defendants' analysis of whether the uncalled witnesses' testimony would have been cumulative."
- "We hold that when a missing witness charge is requested in a civil case, the uncalled witness's testimony may properly be considered cumulative only when it is cumulative of testimony or other evidence favoring the party controlling the witness."
- "It may not be considered cumulative simply because it would repeat or be consistent with an opposing party's evidence."