Majority opinion by Judge Graffeo
New York courts usually leave privilege disputes to the other state. But they may apply New York's reporter shield law and refuse the subpoena when an extremely strong and clear New York public policy is at stake, the reporter reasonably relied on New York law, and appearing in the other state would be substantially likely to force disclosure of confidential sources or contempt for refusing.
Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Lippman, and Rivera.
How we found this rule
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
Under CPL 640.10 (2), although New York courts acting as the sending state ordinarily do not resolve admissibility or privilege questions and leave them to the demanding state, they may consider and apply the New York Shield Law and refuse a subpoena when the witness shows that an extremely strong and clear New York public policy is implicated, there is a substantial likelihood that compelling appearance and testimony in the other jurisdiction would directly offend that policy, and the witness reasonably relied on New York law; thus, a New York court should not issue a subpoena requiring a New York reporter to appear in another state when there is a substantial likelihood the reporter will be compelled to identify confidential sources promised confidentiality or face contempt.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "Application of a limited public policy exception in these unusual circumstances should not upset the Codey rule, which we reaffirm: absent a threatened violation of an extremely strong and clear public policy of this State such as is present here, New York courts adjudicating CPL 640.10 (2) applications should decline to resolve admissibility issues, including privilege claims, so that they can be decided in the demanding state."
- "Thus, the narrow exception we recognize today, which permits a New York court to consider and apply New York's journalist's privilege in relation to issuance of its own process—a subpoena—in a narrow subset of cases, is not tantamount to giving a New York law extraterritorial effect."
- "To obtain relief, a party seeking to avoid issuance of a subpoena under CPL 640.10 (2) will have to establish that a strong public policy is implicated and that there is a substantial likelihood that an order compelling the witness's appearance and testimony in the other jurisdiction would directly offend that policy."
- "Moreover, before the exception may be invoked, the record must indicate that the prospective witness reasonably relied on the protections afforded under New York law when engaged in the conduct that gave rise to the subpoena request."
- "We therefore conclude that an order from a New York court directing a reporter to appear in another state where, as here, there is a substantial likelihood that she will be compelled to identify sources who have been promised confidentiality would offend our strong public policy—a common-law, statutory and constitutional tradition that has played a significant role in this State becoming the media capital of the country if not the world."
- "Here, however, where there is a substantial likelihood that a New York reporter will be compelled to divulge the identity of a confidential source (or face a contempt sanction) if required to appear in the other jurisdiction—a result that would offend the core protection of the Shield Law, a New York public policy of the highest order—all of these hurdles have been cleared."
- "We therefore conclude that the subpoena application should have been denied."
How we compared the opinions
Journalist/source confidentiality protections
Below is the AI's reasoning for why this opinion's rule would increase journalist/source confidentiality protections compared with the rule in Judge Smith's dissent.
New York reporters and their confidential sources would be less protected under the dissent because a New York court could not block an out-of-state subpoena just because the reporter is based in New York. The main opinion allows a New York court to refuse the subpoena when New York’s exceptionally strong Shield Law is likely to be directly undermined—especially when the reporter reasonably relied on New York’s absolute protection for confidential sources and is likely to be forced to identify them or face contempt elsewhere. The dissent instead says that when the reporter’s conversations with sources happened wholly in another state, the privilege question is governed by that state’s law, usually the place of the communication, so New York’s Shield Law does not apply. That makes compelled testimony and source disclosure easier and narrows New York courts’ ability to stop that disclosure before it happens.
Why this subarea? The AI's reasoning for tagging this opinion as journalist/source confidentiality protections:
The rule directly governs when a New York court may refuse to issue a subpoena to protect a reporter from being compelled to reveal confidential sources, making it a Shield Law and compelled-disclosure rule about source confidentiality.
See the methodology for more detail.