Matter of Holmes v. Winter

Date decided
10 December 2013
Vote
Split
in the majority
4
concurring
0
dissenting
3
opinions written
2

Data snapshot: .

Court of Appeals ruling

What was decided

When another state seeks a New York reporter's testimony in a criminal case, and there's a substantial likelihood the reporter must reveal sources promised confidentiality or face contempt there, can a New York court order the reporter to appear?

New York courts usually leave privilege disputes to the other state. But they may apply New York's reporter shield law and refuse the subpoena when an extremely strong and clear New York public policy is at stake, the reporter reasonably relied on New York law, and appearing in the other state would be substantially likely to force disclosure of confidential sources or contempt for refusing.

Subareas

  • Journalist/source confidentiality protections How well journalists can keep sources and reporting materials confidential against subpoenas and forced disclosure.

How each judge voted

7 judges

Majority

  • Journalist/source confidentiality protections Increase

Dissent

  • Journalist/source confidentiality protections Decrease
  • Smith Wrote a dissent
  • Pigott Joined Smith's dissent

Dissent

No direction: this judge did not write an opinion.

  • Read Dissented without a written opinion

The opinions

Plain-language summaries

Each block gives the legal rule our analysis found in one opinion. Click + at the bottom of a block to see that rule in legal terms, the passages it rests on and, where we compared opinions, the AI’s reasoning for each subarea and direction.

Majority opinion by Judge Graffeo

New York courts usually leave privilege disputes to the other state. But they may apply New York's reporter shield law and refuse the subpoena when an extremely strong and clear New York public policy is at stake, the reporter reasonably relied on New York law, and appearing in the other state would be substantially likely to force disclosure of confidential sources or contempt for refusing.

Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Lippman, and Rivera.

Dissent by Judge Smith

New York’s law protecting reporters’ confidential sources can sometimes justify refusing to order a witness to appear in another state’s criminal case. But if the reporter’s source conversations happened entirely in another state, privilege is governed by the forum state’s law or the law of the state most closely tied to the communication, usually where it happened, not New York’s just because the reporter is based in New York.

Also joined by Pigott.

Dissent by Judge Read, without a written opinion

This judge did not write a separate opinion. The court's decision records only the vote, a brief reason, or a pointer to reasoning in another opinion, so our analysis did not extract a rule from this judge.

About this analysis

Methodology

Analysis run 5 October 2026

Covering decisions published between 21 March 2013 and 23 June 2026.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.