Caronia v. Philip Morris USA, Inc.

Date decided
17 December 2013
Vote
Split
in the majority
4
concurring
0
dissenting
2
opinions written
2

Data snapshot: .

Court of Appeals ruling

What was decided

If someone alleges an exposure only increased their risk of future disease and caused no present physical injury or property damage, can they sue for a court-supervised medical-monitoring program?

No. In New York, someone who claims only a higher risk of future disease, without present physical injury or property damage, cannot bring a standalone medical-monitoring claim. Medical monitoring is available only as damages on an existing tort claim after the person proves physical injury and a right to damages.

Subareas

  • Who can be held responsible for an injury How readily legal responsibility for an injury can be established, including who owes a duty of care and how it is proved.

How each judge voted

6 judges

Majority

  • Who can be held responsible for an injury Decrease
  • Pigott Wrote the majority opinion
  • Abdus-Salaam Joined Pigott's majority opinion
  • Graffeo Joined Pigott's majority opinion
  • Read Joined Pigott's majority opinion

Dissent

  • Who can be held responsible for an injury Increase

The opinions

Plain-language summaries

Each block gives the legal rule our analysis found in one opinion. Click + at the bottom of a block to see that rule in legal terms, the passages it rests on and, where we compared opinions, the AI’s reasoning for each subarea and direction.

Majority opinion by Judge Pigott

In New York, someone who claims only a higher risk of future disease, without present physical injury or property damage, cannot bring a standalone medical-monitoring claim. Medical monitoring is available only as damages on an existing tort claim after the person proves physical injury and a right to damages.

Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Graffeo, and Read.

Dissent by Judge Lippman

New York should recognize a separate claim allowing smokers to seek a court-supervised medical-monitoring program when they can prove that tobacco companies’ wrongful conduct increased their risk of cancer.

Also joined by Rivera.

About this analysis

Methodology

Analysis run 5 October 2026

Covering decisions published between 21 March 2013 and 23 June 2026.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.