People v. Carr

Date decided
2 April 2015
Vote
Split
in the majority
5
concurring
0
dissenting
2
opinions written
2

Data snapshot: .

Court of Appeals ruling

What was decided

If a judge privately questions a key trial witness about the witness’s physical or mental condition after missed appearances, and that could bear on credibility rather than scheduling, can the judge keep defense lawyers out?

Unless there is a substantial justification, a judge may not question a witness outside defense counsel’s presence about matters that affect trial issues, including credibility. If the witness’s mental or physical condition could affect credibility rather than just scheduling, defense counsel must be present, and excluding them is a constitutional error that cannot be dismissed as harmless.

Subareas

  • Due process protections How strong the procedural protections are for the accused, from search and questioning through trial, sentencing, and after conviction.

How each judge voted

7 judges

Majority

  • Due process protections Increase

Dissent

  • Due process protections Decrease
  • Fahey Wrote a dissent
  • Pigott Joined Fahey's dissent

The opinions

Plain-language summaries

Each block gives the legal rule our analysis found in one opinion. Click + at the bottom of a block to see that rule in legal terms, the passages it rests on and, where we compared opinions, the AI’s reasoning for each subarea and direction.

Majority opinion by Judge Lippman

Unless there is a substantial justification, a judge may not question a witness outside defense counsel’s presence about matters that affect trial issues, including credibility. If the witness’s mental or physical condition could affect credibility rather than just scheduling, defense counsel must be present, and excluding them is a constitutional error that cannot be dismissed as harmless.

Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Read, Rivera, and Stein.

Dissent by Judge Fahey

A judge may privately handle a purely scheduling or administrative issue without the defense present only if it does not require input from the defendant or lawyers, does not affect any party’s substantial rights, is not likely to give either side a procedural or tactical advantage, and the judge promptly tells the other side what was said and lets them respond when practical and appropriate.

Also joined by Pigott.

About this analysis

Methodology

Analysis run 5 October 2026

Covering decisions published between 21 March 2013 and 23 June 2026.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.