Majority opinion by Judge Jenny Rivera
A worker is doing covered alteration work when the job will make a significant physical change to a structure, and the worker is hurt while doing a necessary preparatory step for that change. The change need not be permanent, but routine maintenance or purely decorative work is not covered.
Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Fahey, Lippman, Pigott, Read, and Stein.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
1. For Labor Law § 240 (1), the analysis does not isolate the moment of injury and ignore the general context of the work; workers employed in an enumerated act are covered even while performing duties ancillary or preparatory to that act, and altering requires a significant physical change to the configuration or composition of the building or structure, not routine maintenance or decorative modification, without any requirement that the change be permanent. 2. Under Labor Law § 240 (2), scaffolding or staging more than twenty feet from the ground or floor must have a safety rail of suitable material properly attached, bolted, braced, or otherwise secured; failure to provide such a rail gives rise to a viable claim under that section. 3. Because the Industrial Code defines construction to include alteration of a structure, a worker engaged in altering a structure is performing construction work within Labor Law § 241 (6).
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "In determining whether plaintiff Joseph Saint was engaged in the type of work covered by section 240 (1), we first consider defendant's contention that we should limit our analysis of plaintiff's activity to the moment of his injury."
- "The Court previously rejected this narrow construction of the statute's application in Prats v Port Auth."
- "of N.Y. & N.J., because "it is neither pragmatic nor consistent with the spirit of the statute to isolate the moment of injury and ignore the general context of the work" ."
- "Based on the context of that work and because the "intent of the statute [is] to protect workers employed in the enumerated acts, even while performing duties ancillary to those acts" (id. at 882), the Court concluded that the plaintiff was engaged in alteration and thus covered under section 240 (1)."
- "Defendant's interpretation would compartmentalize a plaintiff's activity and exclude from the statute's coverage preparatory work essential to the enumerated act."
- "The vinyl removal was a prerequisite to the attachment of the extensions and therefore an integral part of the installation of the extensions."
- "In reaching this determination we apply the definition the Court adopted in Joblon, that the term "altering" in section 240 (1) "requires making a significant physical change to the configuration or composition of the building or structure" (Joblon)."
- "This definition excludes "routine maintenance" and "decorative modifications" (id.)."
- "Similarly unpersuasive is defendant's argument that plaintiff's work is not an alteration within the meaning of section 240 (1) because the statute applies only to permanent changes."
- "There is no support in the text or the case law for this limit on the statute's reach."
- "Nowhere does section 240 (1) impose or even mention a requirement that an alteration be of a permanent and fixed nature (see Labor Law § 240 [1])."
- "Turning to his section 240 (2) claim, this provision requires, in relevant part, that "[s]caffolding or staging more than twenty feet from the ground or floor . . . shall have a safety rail of suitable material properly attached, bolted, braced or otherwise secured . . . .""
- "It is undisputed that the billboard platform was 59 feet above the ground and that there was no safety railing surrounding the upper rear catwalk from which plaintiff fell."
- "Therefore, plaintiff alleged a viable claim under section 240 (2) and its dismissal was error."
- "In determining what constitutes "construction" for purposes of the statute we look to the Industrial Code which, as relevant here, defines construction to include alteration of a structure (12 NYCRR 23-1.4 [b] [13])."
- "With respect to plaintiff's section 241 (6) claim, we agree with plaintiff that he was engaged in "construction work" and thus within the ambit of the statute."
- "Pursuant to section 241 (6), "All areas in which construction, excavation or demolition work is being performed shall be so constructed, shored, equipped, guarded, arranged, operated and conducted as to provide reasonable and adequate protection and safety to the persons employed therein or lawfully frequenting such places.""
- "Since plaintiff was altering the billboard by installing the extension at the time of his injury, his claim comes within section 241 (6)."