Majority opinion by Judge Stein
Under that kind of indemnity clause, an environmental agency notice requires action if its language is coercive and adversarial—for example, it demands a cleanup agreement or payment and warns that, without a prompt response, the agency will do the work itself and seek to recover the costs. Losses from that response are covered.
Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Fahey, Lippman, Pigott, and Rivera.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
Under a contractual indemnification clause limited to environmental losses arising from actions an indemnified party is "required" to take under or in connection with any Environmental Law, a Department of Environmental Conservation potentially responsible party notice letter "requires" action, and resulting losses are indemnifiable, when the letter's particular language is sufficiently coercive and adversarial—threatening litigation and imminent adverse legal and financial consequences, such as by demanding a consent order or payment and warning that the agency will perform the work and seek recovery if no prompt response is made.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "In relevant part, that provision obligated Pyne to "indemnify, defend and hold [the] [b]uyer . . . harmless" for "Environmental Losses" "that arise out of or relate to . . . any environmental remedial, investigatory or monitoring action taken or any other Losses under or relating to any Environmental Law with respect to any of the Company's Real Properties or the Company's assets or operations (past or present), as a result of conditions which exist (or previously existed) on or prior to the Closing Date, provided that Losses under this Section . . . shall only be indemnified by Seller if such Losses arise out of or result from actions by any Indemnified Party that such Indemnified Party is required to take under or in connection with any Environmental Law . . . (and such Loss shall not arise out of or result from communications by such Indemnified Party with any Governmental Entity (except to the extent required under any Environmental Law . . .))" (additional emphasis added)."
- "We conclude that the particular language of the letter at issue threatened imminent adverse legal consequences and was, therefore, sufficiently coercive as to "require" action under the meaning of the indemnification clause."
- "The PRP letter stated that it pertained to an "Urgent Legal Matter," indicated that a prompt reply was "necessary," and set forth the consequences that would flow from Remet's refusal to act."
- "Regardless of whether Remet was designated a potentially responsible party or a responsible party, the letter demanded either a consent order or payment and any language indicating that Remet's response was voluntary must be read in terms of those demands."
- "DEC advised that, "if a signed Consent Order [was] not received within 30 days . . . , all further discussions [would] terminate," and DEC would perform the necessary work itself and then seek recovery from Remet, as a PRP."
- "In that event, the PRP letter "serve[d] as a demand for payment of all monies [DEC] may expend," with interest accruing from the date of the letter."
- "In short, the PRP letter issued to Remet was sufficiently coercive and adversarial as to "require" action "under or in connection with any Environmental Law" pursuant to the sales agreement, given that it threatened litigation and imminent adverse legal and financial consequences pursuant to the ECL (see Borgwarner Corp. v Insurance Co. of N. Am.; see also Carpentier v Hanover Ins. Co.)."
- "The plain language of the governing contractual indemnity provision, together with the language of the PRP letter and the surrounding facts and circumstances, demonstrate that Remet was entitled to indemnification because it was "required," within the meaning of the sales agreement, to act in response to the PRP letter (see generally Drzewinski v Atlantic Scaffold & Ladder Co.)."
- "Accordingly, based on the particular language of the PRP letter and the indemnification clause at issue here, Remet is entitled to contractual indemnification for past and future environmental losses incurred as a result of DEC's investigation and remediation of the Erie Canal site and Supreme Court properly granted summary judgment to plaintiff on liability."