Majority opinion by Judge Jenny Rivera
If a defendant alleges that police or a prosecutor showed a witness the defendant’s image in an unduly suggestive way, the court must hold a pretrial identification hearing; there is no separate trial-preparation exception or preliminary hearing. The prosecution must first show no undue suggestiveness, the defendant ultimately must prove it, and if the procedure was unduly suggestive and the prosecution cannot prove by clear and convincing evidence an independent basis for the identification, the pretrial identification is suppressed and any tainted in-court identification barred.
Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, Fahey, and Pigott.
How we found this rule
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
When a defendant alleges that an out-of-court viewing of the defendant's likeness by a witness was unduly suggestive, the court must hold a Wade hearing to determine whether the police or prosecutor exposed the witness to the defendant's identity in an unduly suggestive manner; there is no separate trial-preparation exception or pre-Wade "Herner hearing" for such viewings. At that hearing, the People bear the initial burden to show a lack of undue suggestiveness, the defendant bears the ultimate burden of proving undue suggestiveness, and if the procedure was unduly suggestive and the People do not establish by clear and convincing evidence an independent source for the identification, the pretrial identification must be suppressed and any tainted in-court identification precluded.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "Although a court may summarily deny a request to suppress evidence where the defendant fails to allege a legal basis for the motion (CPL 710.60 [3]), "so long as the motion alleges undue suggestiveness, the defendant is generally entitled to a Wade hearing" (Boyer)."
- "When a defendant challenges the suggestiveness of an out-of-court viewing of defendant's likeness, the central issue presented for judicial consideration is whether the pretrial display is conducted under circumstances bearing the earmarks of improper influence and unreliability, which create the risk of mistaken identification and thus infect the truth-seeking process."
- "Instead, upon defendant's motion, a court must hold a formal pretrial hearing to determine whether the police or prosecutor conducted an out-of-court identification procedure that exposed the witness to defendant's identity in an unduly suggestive manner (Boyer)."
- "Upon consideration of the applicable statutory mandates and case law, as well as the concerns over mistaken identification and the potential risk of wrongful convictions based on eyewitness error, we conclude that the trial-preparation exception and the procedural mechanism designed to determine its application to any particular case, the so-called Herner hearing, serve as an obstacle to judicial scrutiny of potentially unconstitutionally suggestive identification procedures."
- "The Herner procedure is, furthermore, unnecessary, because a Wade hearing adequately ensures against the admission of an unreliable identification."
- "We agree."
- "We can find no basis to maintain a distinction between viewings of a defendant's image in preparation for trial and any other out-of-court identifications."
- "We therefore see no reason to encumber our courts with an additional pre-Wade hearing."
- "The People bear the initial burden to establish a lack of any undue suggestiveness, but the defendant "bears the ultimate burden of proving that the procedure was unduly suggestive" (Chipp)."
- "If the court finds the procedure to have been unduly suggestive and the People have failed to establish by clear and convincing evidence the existence of an independent source for the identification, the motion is granted (Rahming)."
- "In that case, the pretrial identification is suppressed and an in-court identification tainted by the prior identification procedure precluded (Chipp)."
How we compared the opinions
Due process protections
Below is the AI's reasoning for why this opinion's rule would decrease due process protections compared with the rule in Judge Lippman's dissent.
A person accused of a crime would get a stronger chance to block unreliable eyewitness testimony under the dissent. Both opinions reject any special “trial preparation” carveout and say a prosecutor’s pretrial photo display to a witness must be examined in a Wade hearing—a pretrial hearing on whether the identification process was unfairly suggestive. But the dissent goes further by requiring the prosecution, in a photographic-display case, to produce the photo itself or testimony describing the safeguards used; without that, the prosecution has not met its initial burden, and an in-court identification can be used only if the state proves an independent basis by clear and convincing evidence. Because that demands more concrete proof from the state, and would not let the case stand on the thinner record the main opinion accepted here, it gives defendants more due-process protection.
Why this subarea? The AI's reasoning for tagging this opinion as due process protections:
The rule governs criminal identification procedures by requiring a Wade hearing when undue suggestiveness is alleged, allocating burdens at that hearing, and providing suppression/preclusion remedies for tainted identifications. That directly affects trial-fairness and evidentiary due-process protections in criminal prosecutions.
See the methodology for more detail.