Matter of Tonawanda Seneca Nation v. Noonan

Area of law
Access to Justice
Date decided
23 June 2016
Vote
Unanimous
in the majority
6
concurring
0
dissenting
0
opinion written
1

Data snapshot: .

Court of Appeals ruling

What was decided

When someone files an article 78 challenge to something a judge who serves on more than one court did, must it start in the Appellate Division only if the judge was acting as a Supreme Court or County Court judge?

Yes. Where a court-review challenge is filed against a judge who serves on more than one court, it must be filed based on the court role the judge was acting in when taking the challenged action. It may start in the Appellate Division only if the judge was acting as a Supreme Court or County Court judge; otherwise it must start in Supreme Court.

How each judge voted

6 judges

There were no dissents or concurrences; every participating judge joined the same opinion.

Majority

No direction: this decision has one written opinion.

The opinions

Plain-language summaries

Each block gives the legal rule our analysis found in one opinion. Click + at the bottom of a block to see that rule in legal terms, the passages it rests on and, where we compared opinions, the AI’s reasoning for each subarea and direction.

Majority opinion by Judge Michael J. Garcia

Where a court-review challenge is filed against a judge who serves on more than one court, it must be filed based on the court role the judge was acting in when taking the challenged action. It may start in the Appellate Division only if the judge was acting as a Supreme Court or County Court judge; otherwise it must start in Supreme Court.

Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, DiFiore, Pigott, Rivera, and Stein.

About this analysis

Methodology

Analysis run 5 October 2026

Covering decisions published between 21 March 2013 and 23 June 2026.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.