Majority opinion by Judge Michael J. Garcia
Where a court-review challenge is filed against a judge who serves on more than one court, it must be filed based on the court role the judge was acting in when taking the challenged action. It may start in the Appellate Division only if the judge was acting as a Supreme Court or County Court judge; otherwise it must start in Supreme Court.
Also joined by Abdus-Salaam, DiFiore, Pigott, Rivera, and Stein.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
Venue for an article 78 proceeding against a multi-bench judge is determined by the capacity in which the judge was serving when the challenged action was taken; only when the challenged action was taken in the judge's capacity as a Supreme Court Justice or County Court Judge may the proceeding be commenced in the Appellate Division, and if the judge was acting in another judicial capacity, such as Surrogate's Court Judge, it must be commenced in Supreme Court.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "We reject this argument and hold that the determination of venue for an article 78 proceeding against a multi-bench judge turns on the capacity in which the judge was serving when taking the challenged action."
- "Venue for an article 78 proceeding against a multi-bench judge is determined by the capacity in which that judge was serving when the action that is challenged was taken."
- "The Appellate Division dismissed the petition on jurisdictional grounds, determining that the proceeding must originate in Supreme Court because Judge Noonan's position as Surrogate was not one listed in CPLR 506 (b) (1), which limits article 78 proceedings that may be commenced in the Appellate Division to those against Supreme Court Justices and County Court Judges ."
- "Nor is there a concern here about having Supreme Court Justices review the decisions of their peer judges—under this holding, review by the Supreme Court only occurs where the challenged decision is made by a judge not serving in the capacity of a Supreme or County Court Judge."
- "We hold that because the proceeding was brought against respondent Judge Robert Noonan in his capacity as a Surrogate's Court Judge, the proceeding should have been commenced in Supreme Court."
- "Here, where Judge Noonan was acting as Surrogate with respect to the probate of the will, the Nation's suit challenging those actions should have been brought in Supreme Court (see CPLR 7804 [b])."
- "Respondent in this case was a Surrogate's Court Judge, acting as such in probating the will at issue and the proceeding should have been brought in Supreme Court."