Majority opinion by Judge Jenny Rivera
A person claiming fraudulent inducement must plead an actual out-of-pocket money loss directly caused by the fraud. Lost business opportunities, lost profits, a speculative lost deal, or possible future harm do not count, and nominal damages are unavailable. If that is the defect, the claim should be dismissed, and discovery cannot be used just to hunt for support.
Also joined by DiFiore, Fahey, Stein, and Wilson.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
1. To state a fraudulent inducement claim, the plaintiff must plead actual out-of-pocket pecuniary loss directly caused by the fraud; lost business opportunities, lost profits, speculative loss of a contractual bargain, and possible future damages are not recoverable. 2. Nominal damages are unavailable for fraudulent inducement because actual harm is an element of that tort. 3. Discovery is not warranted when the defect in the pleading is the plaintiff's inability to recover for the alleged injury; the mere hope that discovery might provide factual support for a patently defective cause of action is insufficient to avoid dismissal.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "To allege a cause of action based on fraud, plaintiff must assert "a misrepresentation or a material omission of fact which was false and known to be false by defendant, made for the purpose of inducing the other party to rely upon it, justifiable reliance of the other party on the misrepresentation or material omission and injury" (Lama Holding Co. v Smith Barney [citations omitted])."
- "Critically, "[a] false representation does not, without more, give rise to a right of action, either at law or in equity, in favor of the person to whom it is addressed. To give rise, under any circumstances, to a cause of action, either in law or equity, reliance on the false representation must result in injury. . . . "If the fraud causes no loss, then the plaintiff has suffered no damages" (Sager v Friedman)."
- "In New York, as in multiple other states, " '[t]he true measure of damage is indemnity for the actual pecuniary loss sustained as the direct result of the wrong' or what is known as the 'out-of-pocket' rule" (Lama Holding, quoting Reno v Bull)."
- "These are factual assertions of the quintessential lost opportunity, which is not a recoverable out-of-pocket loss (see Lama Holding)."
- "As this Court has repeatedly stated, such damage is "disallowed as too speculative a recovery" (Dress Shirt Sales; see also Lama Holding)."
- "Under that rule, "[d]amages are to be calculated to compensate plaintiffs for what they lost because of the fraud, not to compensate them for what they might have gained . . . . [T]here can be no recovery of profits which would have been realized in the absence of fraud" (id. at 421, citing Foster v Di Paolo, AFA Protective Sys. v American Tel. & Tel. Co. and Cayuga Harvester v Allischalmers Corp.)."
- "Moreover, this Court has "consistent[ly] refus[ed] to allow damages for fraud based on the loss of a contractual bargain, the extent and, indeed. . . the very existence of which is completely undeterminable and speculative" (Dress Shirt Sales v Hotel Martinique Assoc.)."
- "Similarly inadequate to satisfy his pleading burden are plaintiff's allegations that he might incur litigation expenses and potential loss of reputation if named in a civil action by the other chef."
- "These are not claims of actual out-of-pocket loss but speculative claims of possible future damages and fare no better than his lost profits claim."
- "Since actual harm is an element of fraudulent inducement (see Eurycleia Partners, LP v Seward & Kissel, LLP) and there is no compelling reason to carve out an exception for such cause of action, as a general matter or specifically in this case, plaintiff is not entitled to nominal damages."
- "Nominal damages are not available when actual harm is an element of the tort (Restatement [Second] of Torts § 907; accord Lee S. Kreindler et al., New York Law of Torts §§ 1:74, 21:2 [West's NY Prac Series Aug. 2016 Update])."
- "Contrary to plaintiff's argument, under the circumstances of this case, discovery is not warranted because the defect in the pleading is with plaintiff's inability to recover for the alleged injury. "[T]he mere hope that discovery might provide some factual support for a cause of action is insufficient to avoid dismissal of a patently defective cause of action" (Mandarin Trading Ltd. v Wildenstein [citation omitted])."