Majority opinion by Judge Jenny Rivera
Under the motor-vehicle law on police-frequency scanners, a vehicle is treated as equipped with a scanner even if it is not attached, so long as the scanner is readily accessible for immediate use in the vehicle, including on the driver's person.
Also joined by DiFiore, Fahey, Feinman, Garcia, and Wilson.
How we found this rule
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
1. Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397 does not require a prohibited radio receiving set to be physically attached to a motor vehicle; a vehicle is "equipped" with the device so long as the device is readily accessible for immediate use, or otherwise ready for efficient service, in the vehicle. 2. The factual part of a misdemeanor information must establish reasonable cause and a prima facie case, and, when given a fair and not overly restrictive or technical reading, allegations that a defendant operated a vehicle while carrying in his jacket pocket a scanner that was easily accessible, ready for use, and capable of receiving police radio signals are facially sufficient to plead a Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397 violation.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "We conclude the statute does not require that the prohibited device be physically attached to the motor vehicle."
- "Giving "equip" its commonly understood meaning, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397 applies regardless of whether the prohibited device is physically attached to the motor vehicle, so long as the device is ready for efficient service."
- "Given the purpose of the legislation—to reduce access inside motor vehicles to police radio signals—it is irrelevant whether the device is mounted, lying on the seat or in a defendant's pocket so long as the device is readily accessible for immediate use in the vehicle."
- "Contrary to defendant's contention, Verdino stands for the proposition that a motor vehicle is equipped with the device when the device is readily available for use."
- "Turning to the sufficiency of the accusatory instrument in defendant's case, we apply our well established rules that the factual part of a facially sufficient misdemeanor information must show "reasonable cause" that a "prima facie" case exists against the defendant (People v Kalin; CPL 100.15, 100.40)."
- ""So long as the factual allegations of an information give an accused notice sufficient to prepare a defense and are adequately detailed to prevent a defendant from being tried twice for the same offense, they should be given a fair and not overly restrictive or technical reading" (People v Casey)."
- "Applying "a fair and not overly restrictive or technical reading" to these factual allegations (id.), the superseding information was facially sufficient to establish reasonable cause to believe defendant violated Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397."
- "Here,the People's superseding information set forth sworn allegations that the deponent officer observed defendant operating a tow truck on a public roadway while carrying a device in his jacket pocket, easily accessible and ready for use, that was capable of receiving police radio signals from two precincts."
How we compared the opinions
Criminal liability & punishment
Below is the AI's reasoning for why this opinion's rule would increase criminal liability & punishment compared with the rule in Judge Stein's dissent.
The dissent would make it harder to charge a driver with this misdemeanor for having a police scanner in a vehicle. The main opinion reads Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397 broadly: a vehicle is “equipped” if the scanner is readily accessible and ready to use in the car, even if it is just in the driver’s pocket. The dissent reads the statute more narrowly and says the scanner must have some real connection to the vehicle itself—such as being linked to the car, working through it, or charging from it—so mere possession inside the vehicle is not enough. That narrower rule removes some conduct from the statute’s reach, which means less criminal liability and less potential punishment; under the dissent’s approach, the scanner in the driver’s jacket pocket would not support this charge.
Why this subarea? The AI's reasoning for tagging this opinion as criminal liability & punishment:
The rule defines the scope of Vehicle and Traffic Law § 397 by holding that a vehicle is “equipped” with a prohibited scanner even if the device is not physically attached, so long as it is readily accessible for immediate use in the vehicle. That directly affects what conduct satisfies this criminal offense.
See the methodology for more detail.