Majority opinion by Judge DiFiore
When a worker qualifies for extra workers' compensation after a 50% or greater loss of an arm, leg, hand, or foot and has used up the fixed schedule award, that extra award is subject to the same maximum-week limits as other permanent partial disability benefits. It ends earlier if the worker becomes entitled to Social Security old-age benefits.
Also joined by Fahey, Feinman, Garcia, Rivera, and Stein.
How we found this rule
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
Workers' Compensation Law § 15 (3) (v)'s directive that additional compensation be determined "in accordance with paragraph w" incorporates the entirety of Workers' Compensation Law § 15 (3) (w)'s compensation framework, including both the weekly-payment formula and the durational limits on the maximum number of weeks payable; a paragraph (v) award therefore is capped under paragraph (w) and ceases earlier if the claimant becomes entitled to old-age insurance benefits under the social security act.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "Paragraph (v) does not include a formula or schedule for determining the amount of additional compensation available, but states that "[s]uch additional compensation shall be determined in accordance with paragraph w of this subdivision"—the provision addressing calculation of non-schedule permanent partial disability benefits (Workers' Compensation Law § 15 [3] [v])."
- "(v) adopts, without qualification, paragraph (w)'s process for determining the size and scope of a disability award."
- "Therefore, the plain text of paragraph"
- "(v) incorporates the entirety of paragraph (w)'s framework for calculating benefits, including both the paragraph"
- "Under paragraph (w), the weekly compensation award is two thirds of the difference between the injured worker's average weekly wages prior to the injury and the worker's earning capacity after the injury."
- "Paragraph (w) also specifies the number of weeks the worker will receive that weekly sum, based on the percentage of lost wage-earning capacity."
- "(w) formula for determining a weekly benefit payment and the portion of that provision setting the maximum number of weeks the sum is to be paid."
- "By incorporating the entirety of paragraph (w)'s framework for calculating benefits, paragraph"
- "(v) provides additional compensation lasting a maximum number of weeks as a supplement to the schedule award the worker already received."
- "Rather, under the plain language of paragraph (v), additional compensation awards are calculated pursuant to the formula and durational provisions of paragraph (w), terminating earlier if or when a claimant becomes eligible for age-based Social Security benefits."
- "Lastly, paragraph (v) states that an additional compensation award "shall cease on the date the disabled employee receives or is entitled to receive old-age insurance benefits under the social security act" (Workers' Compensation Law § 15 [3] [v])."
- "Paragraph (v)'s requirement that such payment terminates if the worker becomes eligible for age-based Social Security payments (regardless of how many weeks have passed) merely places another limit, where applicable, on the additional compensation a claimant can receive."
- "Put another way, once claimants are entitled to age-based Social Security benefits, they are no longer eligible to receive additional compensation even if they have not yet reached the maximum number of weeks applicable under paragraph (w)."
How we compared the opinions
Workers' compensation benefits access
Below is the AI's reasoning for why this opinion's rule would decrease workers' compensation benefits access compared with the rule in Judge Wilson's dissent.
Workers with very severe arm, leg, hand, or foot injuries would be able to keep getting workers’ compensation longer under the dissent. The main opinion treats the cross-reference to paragraph (w) as importing not just the weekly-payment formula but also paragraph (w)’s maximum-week caps, so the worker’s added benefits end when that cap is reached, even if old-age Social Security is still years away; here, that meant a 275-week cutoff. The dissent reads paragraph (w) differently: it uses paragraph (w) only to calculate the weekly amount, while allowing separate additional compensation for any post-award period when the worker’s lost earning capacity is caused solely by that injury, stopping only when the worker becomes entitled to old-age Social Security benefits. Because that rule removes the paragraph (w) time cap from these added benefits, it expands access to and entitlement to workers’ compensation.
Why this subarea? The AI's reasoning for tagging this opinion as workers' compensation benefits access:
The rule directly defines entitlement to and duration of workers' compensation benefits under WCL § 15 (3) (v) by importing paragraph (w)'s week caps and applying the old-age Social Security cutoff, thereby limiting continued access to additional compensation.
See the methodology for more detail.