Matter of Harkenrider v. Hochul

Area of law
Voting & Elections
Date decided
27 April 2022
Vote
Split
in the majority
4
concurring
0
dissenting
3
opinions written
4

Data snapshot: .

Court of Appeals ruling

What was decided

If the independent redistricting commission's first plan is rejected but it never submits the required second plan, can the legislature still pass its own redistricting maps?

No. Redistricting must go through the independent redistricting commission unless a court steps in. If the first plan is rejected, the commission must submit a second plan for a vote without changes. Only if the second plan is rejected may the legislature enact maps by amending a commission plan. If the deadline has passed, the legislature cannot cure the defect, and a court may adopt maps with a neutral expert.

Subareas

  • Protection against politically tilted district maps How strong the safeguards are against district maps drawn to favor a party or incumbents, including the ability to get them redrawn.

How each judge voted

7 judges

Dissent

  • Protection against politically tilted district maps Decrease

Dissent

  • Protection against politically tilted district maps Decrease

Dissent

  • Protection against politically tilted district maps Decrease

The opinions

Plain-language summaries

Each block gives the legal rule our analysis found in one opinion. Click + at the bottom of a block to see that rule in legal terms, the passages it rests on and, where we compared opinions, the AI’s reasoning for each subarea and direction.

Majority opinion by Judge DiFiore

Redistricting must go through the independent redistricting commission unless a court steps in. If the first plan is rejected, the commission must submit a second plan for a vote without changes. Only if the second plan is rejected may the legislature enact maps by amending a commission plan. If the deadline has passed, the legislature cannot cure the defect, and a court may adopt maps with a neutral expert.

Also joined by Cannataro, Garcia, and Singas.

Dissent by Judge Shirley Troutman

The legislature may vote only on redistricting maps that first come from the independent redistricting committee through the state constitution’s exclusive process. A map passed outside that process is unconstitutional and must be struck down. If a court finds that kind of violation, it must give the legislature a full and reasonable chance to fix it while following that process as closely as possible.

Dissent by Judge Rowan D. Wilson

When a court in a redistricting case finds a constitutional violation, it must give the legislature a full, reasonable chance to fix the map itself and cannot send the job to a court-appointed outside official. Districts can be struck down only if a challenger proves beyond a reasonable doubt that they were drawn to reduce competition or to favor or hurt incumbents, candidates, or parties; partisan effects alone are not enough.

Dissent by Judge Jenny Rivera

The legislature may enact its own redistricting law if the commission has already submitted two plans for consideration, the legislature approves neither, and the commission then submits nothing by the second constitutional deadline, so the law is not automatically void. State law likewise requires each house to introduce its own bill, with any amendments it thinks necessary, if the commission misses a submission deadline but turns over all plans it has, including drafts, and the underlying data.

About this analysis

Methodology

Analysis run 5 October 2026

Covering decisions published between 21 March 2013 and 23 June 2026.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.