Majority opinion by Judge Jenny Rivera
When prosecutors seek a repeat violent felony sentence, the judge must ask the defendant personally whether to dispute any allegation in the prosecutor's statement, including allegations about the prior conviction or past incarceration. The judge cannot accept defense counsel's concession over the defendant's express objection, and must let the defendant explain the objection and, if needed, hold a hearing.
Also joined by Cannataro, Garcia, Halligan, Singas, Troutman, and Wilson.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
1. Where an alleged error is constitutional in nature, the court first considers whether the evidence of guilt is overwhelming and, if it is, then whether there is a reasonable possibility that the error might have contributed to the conviction; if the evidence is overwhelming and there is no reasonable possibility the error contributed to the conviction, the error is harmless. 2. Under CPL 400.15 (3), the sentencing court must ask the defendant personally whether they wish to controvert any allegation in the prosecution's predicate violent felony statement; the right to controvert is personal to the defendant, so the court may not accept defense counsel's decision not to controvert over the defendant's express objection, and the defendant is entitled to an opportunity to explain the objection and, if appropriate, a hearing under CPL 400.15 (5).
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "Since the alleged error is constitutional in nature, first, we "consider whether the evidence of [ ] defendant's guilt is overwhelming" (People v Ortega, citing People v Mairena)."
- "If it is, we then decide whether there was "a reasonable possibility that the error might have contributed to defendant's conviction" (id. [internal quotation marks omitted])."
- "The record therefore contains overwhelming evidence of defendant's guilt."
- "Given the quantity and quality of that evidence, even if some is circumstantial, there is no reasonable possibility that the eyewitness's in-court identification, which the prosecution barely referenced in summation and only as part of an argument that four other witnesses also identified defendant, contributed to his conviction."
- "Thus, we reject defendant's request for a new trial, as the error he alleges was harmless."
- "CPL 400.15 (3), titled "preliminary examination," further states that: "The defendant must be given a copy of [the alleged predicate felony conviction] statement and the court must ask [them] whether [they] wish[ ] to controvert any allegation made therein. If the defendant wishes to controvert any allegation in the statement [they] must specify the particular allegation or allegations [they] wish[ ] to controvert. Uncontroverted allegations in the statement shall be deemed to have been admitted by the defendant.""
- "Based on the full text of CPL 400.15 (3) and its placement in the predicate sentencing statutory scheme, we conclude that a court must ask the defendant personally if they wish to controvert any allegations in the prosecution's statement."
- "These factors, considered together, make clear that the term "defendant," as written in CPL 400.15 (3), refers to the defendant personally."
- "As the right to controvert set forth in CPL 400.15 is personal to the defendant, the court erred in refusing to hear defendant on the matter, where he expressly objected to defense counsel's statement that he did not want to be heard."
- "Defendant is entitled to an opportunity to explain his objection and to a hearing, if appropriate, under CPL 400.15 (5)."
- "The statute mandates a hearing "[w]here the defendant controverts an allegation in the statement and the uncontroverted allegations in such statement are not sufficient to support a finding that the defendant has been subjected to a predicate violent felony conviction" (CPL 400.15 [5])."