Majority opinion by Judge Shirley Troutman
A criminal defendant loses the constitutional right to a 12-person jury if clear and convincing evidence shows the defendant egregiously interfered with a sworn juror after deliberations began and the juror had to be excused. The trial judge must then decide case by case whether to continue with fewer than 12 jurors, declare a mistrial, or take a less severe step.
Also joined by Cannataro, Garcia, Halligan, Rivera, Singas, and Wilson.
The rule above is a plain-language restatement of the legal rule our AI process identified for this opinion. The restatement is meant to make that rule easier to read, not to change its legal meaning. We only use the legal rule, not its restatement, to identify the direction of an opinion in a given subarea.
The underlying legal rule:
1. A defendant forfeits the constitutional right to trial by a jury of 12 when there is clear and convincing evidence that the defendant engaged in egregious conduct affecting a sworn juror after the jury has commenced its deliberations, requiring that juror's discharge. 2. Forfeiture of the right to a jury of 12 does not necessarily require the court to proceed to verdict with fewer than 12 jurors; the court must decide how to proceed on a case-by-case basis, in the sound discretion of the trial court and with due consideration to all the facts and circumstances, and may proceed with fewer than 12 jurors, declare a mistrial, or impose a less drastic sanction.
Before any rule identified by the AI is displayed or used to determine the direction of an opinion on a subarea, the AI selects passages from the opinion that support the legal rule it identified. A separate AI check then confirms that those passages fully support the rule. The AI selected these passages from the opinion to support this legal rule:
- "Because the constitutional amendments and decisions since Cancemi transformed the constitutional guarantee of a jury of 12 into a personal right, defendant may waive the right or, in a case such as this one, forfeit it by engaging in misconduct."
- "We thus conclude that a defendant who engages in egregious conduct affecting a sworn juror after the jury has commenced its deliberations, requiring the discharge of that juror, forfeits the right to a jury of 12."
- "We hold that in these exceedingly rare circumstances where there was clear and convincing evidence that defendant engaged in egregious conduct affecting a sworn juror after the jury commenced its deliberations, requiring the discharge of that juror, defendant forfeited the right to a jury of 12 persons and, there being no alternate jurors to substitute for the dismissed juror, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in proceeding with the remaining 11 jurors."
- "The court applied the standards for forfeiture of that right as set forth in People v Geraci and found by clear and convincing evidence that defendant, believing he could obtain a favorable verdict or a mistrial, intentionally engaged in jury tampering, conduct that resulted in the foreperson's inability to continue to serve as a juror."
- "We conclude that only " 'egregious conduct' " toward a sworn juror can result in a forfeiture of the right to a jury of 12 (Shanks)."
- "Defendant's misconduct occurred after the jury had already begun its deliberations."
- "While the removal of a deliberating juror is not a sufficient condition of a forfeiture, it is most assuredly a necessary condition."
- "It does not necessarily follow, however, that the appropriate course of action in every instance is to proceed to verdict with a jury of fewer than 12 persons."
- "Courts must decide how to proceed on a case-by-case basis, giving due consideration to all the facts and circumstances and the decision is one we commit to the sound discretion of the trial court."
- "Based upon these facts and circumstances, we hold that the court properly exercised its discretion in proceeding with the remaining 11 jurors."
- "There will be cases where it is appropriate for the court to declare a mistrial despite a defendant's misconduct directed towards the jury or to impose some less drastic sanction ."