Michael G. Hayes

Court
Supreme Court, Dutchess County
How seated
Elected
Term
2019–2028
years on the bench
13
metrics
9
measured
6
linked decisions
26
Compare in Dutchess County

Profile data snapshot: .

Trial court metrics

Nine metrics

Read each metric as a fact about Judge Hayes. Publication Rate · 1.4 decisions per year means: 17 published decisions over 12 years. The bar under it compares that with the other Dutchess County judges who have this metric: higher than 69.2% of them. Nine metrics in all: six measured, three not applicable.

Public Discipline

Admonitions or censures from the Commission on Judicial Conduct

0

Publication Rate

How often this judge publishes a written decision

1.4

Suppression Reversal Rate

How often a higher court overturned a decision to admit contested evidence

0

Excessive Sentence Findings

Appellate findings that a sentence was excessive

1

Excessive Sentence Reductions

Prison years reduced by appellate findings that a sentence was excessive

12

Reassigned Reversals

Cases reversed on appeal and moved to a different judge

0

Favored Commercial Bonds

Blocked Affordable Bail

Disproportionate Carcerality

Decisions

25 on record

Each entry is a written decision by Judge Hayes. Published Decisions appeared in the State Reporter database because Judge Hayes chose to make them available to the public, which is what the Publication Rate metric counts. NYSCEF decisions were filed in the courts’ electronic filing system but were not sent for publication to a wider audience. Therefore, they are not counted in the Publication Rate metric.

Appellate rulings

One on record

Each entry is a case Judge Hayes decided that a higher court later ruled on, with a link to that ruling. These are the appellate decisions that underlie some of the metrics above.

Excessive sentences

1 ruling

Methodology

About this analysis

Where the data comes from and how each figure is calculated.

Analysis run 14 October 2026

Each metric draws on a different source, covers a different period, and updates on its own schedule.

Scrutinize

Contact

Report an error on a page, ask about the data, or write to us about anything else.